Monday, September 29, 2014

Isabella Nugent's Reaction Paper #1

Isabella Nugent
Professor McKinney
Slavery in the US
September 30, 2014
The Search for Humanity
            American Slavery and Saltwater Slavery are able to enlighten a reader more about the origins, the process, and the aftermath of slavery than all four years of any high school history courses could. It is common knowledge to American students of all ages that slavery existed as a horrendous blight on our otherwise proud history, before being essentially outlawed by President Lincoln with the Emancipation Proclamation. Unfortunately, the dry facts of history sometimes leave out the unspeakable truths of slavery that, if widely understood, would bring a much deeper level of emotion and understanding to the topic for all students of American history. Throughout the reading, Peter Kolchin and Stephanie Smallwood are able to illustrate with vivid detail so many aspects of the slave trade, which in turn insight incredible feelings and empathy for modern day readers towards the real life people that suffered during such a dreadful, horrific existence in our history.
The first book that the class discussed was Saltwater Slavery written by Stephanie E. Smallwood. Having a very limited knowledge of the Slave Trade, Smallwood wasted no time jumping into the history of the Slave Trade. Throughout the first chapter, Smallwood explains how the original demand for gold quickly went hand in hand with the demand for slaves. Smallwood states,
But a rapidly growing demand for labor… meant that English traders would look to the region to serve as a dual market for the purchase of gold and people, and the pull of the Atlantic market for slaves would henceforth be felt on the Gold Coast as it had elsewhere in Africa in the preceding two centuries[1].
Money is a universal path to power. When it became abundantly clear that with more labor comes more money; the slave trade began to flourish in the new colonies. In other words, it was a shortcut, for a white man to become wealthy on the backs of slaves, without putting in his own sweat and tears. With this mentality, the need for slaves increased substantially and those handling the shipment and commerce of human labor had to adapt to the growing demand.. In a very short period of time, this living, breathing commodity quickly lost any remaining source of humanity as they were now considered to be simply “human cargo”[2]. In other words, these human beings were viewed and treated as if they were furniture being shipped across the Atlantic, with often less care. Smallwood describes the living conditions of the slaves before and during the slave commerce and transportation. This was quite tough to read, not because it was hard to understand, but because while reading, one needs to constantly keep in mind that this is not fiction, or a scene from an overly graphic Hollywood movie, but the brutal, vicious reality for a fellow human.  Thousands of slaves were kept in a small, underground spaces so they could not escape, chained to the boat. Violence was not unusual and nutrition and sanitation were not a priority.  Smallwood explains, “Meant not to support health but rather simply to ensure subsistence, the diet on which captives tried to survive provided, at best, a consistent intake of nutritionally empty calories”[3]. Food is a necessity for living. Captured like a wild animal, torn from their home and family, beaten and humiliated, the slaves were then also deprived of basic nutrition for sustenance. 
            Smallwood made it very clear that even though a boat was only built to carry a certain amount of ‘cargo’, the captains and traders would often literally cram as many living bodies into the below deck space for increased profit. Smallwood writes, “Slaves became, for the purpose of transatlantic shipment, mere physical units that could be arranged and molded at will- whether folded together spoonlike in rows or flattened side by side in a plane” [4]. This one description proves that not only were these humans treated as if they were furniture but the main concern for the traders was the overall profit they were going to make without zero consideration that their merchandise were living, breathing souls. On page 71, Smallwood described that the little space that was left, would not be used as legroom, but instead would be filled by a child so no space was wasted. Not only are they taking away every ounce of freedom from these people but they are also taking away any sense of humanity they have left. As the reading continued, Smallwood explains that the only way they would stop loading slaves onto the ship is if it became a risk to their money. In other words, if the slaves began to die on the ship, it would only hurt their pockets. Another astonishing quotation that was striking was when Smallwood states, “Women were more valuable than men on the African market for slaves, but women were also easier both to obtain and to dispose of”[5]. Once again these people are being described as an object that can easily be replaced if damaged or rendered worthless. To envision a loved one, by actually putting a face to the experience, slavery is such a violation of humanity, it is practically impossible to understand how another human being could commit such atrocities, much less thousands who supported this commerce of human labor.
            In addition to the immense physical suffering, the psychological and emotional anguish would have been equally as great. Imagine being suddenly captured, held hostage, put on a boat in essentially a closed box for weeks on end, with absolutely no understanding of what is happening or where you are. Due to that lack of information, the slaves were forced to come up with their own sense of reasoning to explain their living nightmare. Smallwood discusses their culture and traditions and how it played such a significant role during both their transportation across the ocean, as well as their immersion into their new daily existence in the New World. Every ‘fact’ that they gather, every scrap of information about where they are going, how they are getting there, and what is going to happen to them upon arrival,  is “a rumor-based body of knowledge of their own”[6].  They have no sense of time, location, or sense of meaning as they are shoved in the bottom of a boat, surrounded by strangers. It is impossible to imagine how an individual brain even moves past this type of trauma. The one aspect an enslaved person might have to cling to while having lost all sense of physical freedom, would be his or her culture and beliefs, to grasp on to what little sense of humanity they have left. Although suicide is a naturally considered a tragedy, for a slave it was one means of escape, figuratively and literally, and for him or her to die on their own terms. During such desperate times, taking one’s life to put an end to the seemingly never-ending suffering, was a way to maintain one’s own dignity, especially if the person had a belief in an after life of any type. Suicide might release their soul from slavery even if it ended their life. Many years after the Civil War, although slaves were gaining their freedom, Peter Kolchin notes that due to “legal discrimination and vicious hostility” a black man still was far from being considered ‘free’[7].
            Regardless of how shameful a period in the past may be, it can obviously never be changed. Slavery is a fact, a horrible chapter in the history of a great country. The greatest gift that can be given to the descendants of such a tragedy is to focus attention on the harsh details so that such events are never repeated. It may seem highly improbable that slavery could ever reemerge, but today’s citizens must learn from history so that a greater understanding exists towards groups of American society that even today may not have the same opportunities in their communities because of decades of discrimination and racism.




[1] Stephanie Smallwood, Saltwater Slavery a Middle Passage from Africa to American Diaspora (Harvard University Press 2008),18-19
[2] ibid., 9
[3] Stephanie Smallwood, Saltwater Slavery a Middle Passage from Africa to American Diaspora (Harvard University Press 2008),44
[4] ibid., 68
[5] ibid.; 83
[6] Stephanie Smallwood, Saltwater Slavery a Middle Passage from Africa to American Diaspora (Harvard University Press 2008),130
[7] Peter Kolchin. American Slavery, 1619-1877. (New York: Hill and Wang, 1993),

No comments:

Post a Comment